A self-described "total sceptic" of skincare lotions used this serum for a few days. His partner then asked if he'd had Botox to remove his laughter lines. A woman who was on the verge of booking actual Botox appointments tried it as a last resort, and cancelled those appointments. Meanwhile, another buyer took careful before-and-after photos over a full month and saw absolutely nothing.

This is the NIVEA Q10 Anti-Wrinkle Power Expert Wrinkle Filler Serum - a product that has over 1,300 ratings, an Amazon's Choice badge, and 10,000 units sold in the last month alone. At just under eight pounds, it's also one of the cheapest targeted wrinkle treatments you can buy. But the reviews tell two completely different stories, and after reading all 99 of the most recent ones, we think we know why.

The Product: What You're Actually Putting on Your Face

This is a targeted serum, not a general moisturiser. That distinction matters because a chunk of the negative reviews seem to treat it like an all-over face cream, which it's not designed to be. The 15ml tube is deliberately small because you're meant to apply it to specific problem areas: forehead lines, crow's feet, lip lines, and nasolabial folds.

The formula centres on what NIVEA calls a "5% Active Complex" combining Pure Coenzyme Q10 (an antioxidant your skin produces less of as you age) with Bioxifill peptides. NIVEA claims this combination penetrates 10 layers deep into the skin to boost collagen production. The serum works on two levels: an immediate surface film that temporarily smooths fine lines within minutes, and a longer-term treatment that targets deeper wrinkles over several weeks.

It's made in Italy, suitable for all skin types according to NIVEA, and is both plant-based and vegetarian. The tube has a precision applicator tip that lets you target exactly where you want the product to go.

The Success Stories: When This Serum Actually Works

When this product works for someone, it really works. And the pattern in positive reviews is surprisingly consistent.

The standout review, with 21 helpful votes, comes from Lou, who almost gave up on the serum entirely. She'd been applying a thin smear for five days and saw barely any difference. Then she accidentally squeezed out too much product, applied it thicker, and the lines on her forehead disappeared. She started using a thicker application under makeup and wrote: "I was taking off my makeup and realised I could barely see any lines." She rated it 10/10.

That experience is backed up by dozens of others. Tracey J, a repeat buyer, says it "absorbs quickly, isn't greasy and leaves my skin feeling smooth and hydrated." She's noticed her fine lines look softer. Michelle Holdsworth is realistic about it - "it's not a miracle cream, but definitely saw a difference on first application, it is smoothing out lip lines." Her review picked up helpful votes because of that honesty.

Then there's Smittenkitten, who was about to book Botox for dimpling on her chin. The serum didn't work immediately, but after a week, the dimpled texture was "definitely less noticeable" and she put the Botox on hold. Wilko's beautician actually remarked on the improvement in her skin - she's now on an Amazon subscription.

The people who love this serum tend to share a few traits: they use it on targeted areas rather than all over, they apply enough product (not just a trace), and they give it at least a week before judging.

The Other Side: Why Nearly a Third of Buyers Are Disappointed

About 28% of reviewers gave this one or two stars, and their complaints fall into two distinct categories.

The first group simply didn't see results. Hejmy used it for a full month, took before-and-after photos, and reported "absolutely no difference even in the fine wrinkles." That review has six helpful votes. G. Leader used it alongside other NIVEA Q10 products for two months and said her skin looked no better than when she was using a cheap high street moisturiser. Sarah J tried it for a month and said she'd "score it zero if I could." These aren't unreasonable people - they gave the product time, followed instructions, and it just didn't deliver for them.

The second group had skin reactions, and this is the more concerning pattern. Delma Fenton experienced "red, burning skin and puffy cheek after 4 days." Shantel's eye area went "red, puffy and blotchy, and also really dry." Anniemac found she could only use it on her forehead because her nasal and mouth area reacted with soreness, itching, and small spots. Laulauev described an "acne type rash" around the application areas. If you have sensitive skin, patch test this one first - that's not optional advice.

One other complaint worth flagging: the fragrance. Ashley found it "very scented" and said it made her eyes water all day. If you're sensitive to fragranced skincare, be aware this isn't fragrance-free.

The Secret the Happy Reviewers Share (That NIVEA Doesn't Emphasise Enough)

Reading through all 99 reviews, a pattern jumped out that neither NIVEA's marketing nor most review summaries mention: application thickness matters enormously.

Lou's accidental discovery of thicker application turning a non-result into a "10/10" product isn't an isolated case. Dan's three-star review noted that it "does reduce wrinkles due to the skin coloured cream" and provides "an immediate reduction" but nothing long-term. He rated it mediocre. Compare that to Little Pig, who uses it to "target around my eye, lips, small wrinkles" and finds it "really does look better within minutes." Same product, different techniques, completely different experiences.

The official instructions say to "spread the face care serum evenly with fingertips," but they don't specify how much to use. Based on what happy reviewers describe, you need more than you'd think for a 15ml tube. This connects to another common complaint - A Mian gave one star, saying the tube was "filled with AIR" and finished after "3 tiny uses." If you're applying it generously to get the best results, that 15ml tube will not last long. At 15 grams, you're paying the equivalent of £53.20 per 100g - reasonable for a serum, but you should know the tube won't last months.

Under Makeup: The Unexpected Use Case

Something NIVEA doesn't heavily promote but reviewers have figured out on their own: this serum doubles as a surprisingly good makeup primer.

One reviewer wrote that it "goes on beautifully, requires only a little bit, and works well as a primer under foundation for smoothing out lines" - that review has three helpful votes. Tricia uses it "all the time under my makeup." Ron Waller's wife reports it's "simple to apply, has a pleasant smell and is not oily" - all qualities you'd want in something sitting under foundation.

There is one caveat with this use though. Granny gave it two stars because when she brushed foundation over the serum, it "peeled off in bits." Robyn mentioned it "goes bitty if you touch the eyes after use." The fix, based on what successful reviewers describe, is letting the serum fully absorb before applying makeup on top. Rush it, and you'll get pilling. Give it a minute or two, and it creates a smooth base.

Who Should Buy This (and Who Really Shouldn't)

This serum is a strong buy if: you have fine lines and early wrinkles rather than deep-set ones, you're looking for something to smooth out forehead lines or lip lines specifically, you want a lightweight product that works under makeup, or you've been considering more expensive treatments and want to try the affordable route first. Smittenkitten's experience of postponing Botox after using this is the best-case scenario, and it happens more often than you'd expect at this price point.

Skip this one if: you have sensitive or reactive skin (the pattern of rash and redness complaints is too consistent to ignore), you expect dramatic results on deep wrinkles (it's a "filler" that softens appearance, not a cosmetic procedure), you dislike fragranced skincare, or you need a product that lasts a long time per tube.

The reviewer split on this product isn't random. It correlates strongly with skin type, application method, and expectations. People who target specific areas with enough product and give it a week tend to be thrilled. People who apply a thin layer all over and expect deep wrinkles to vanish tend to be furious.

Our Rating: 3.5 out of 5

The overall Amazon rating sits at 4.1 stars across 1,309 ratings, but our sample of 99 recent reviews averages a more honest 3.53. That gap suggests the older reviews may have been kinder, or that expectations have risen over time.

We're going with 3.5 out of 5. This is a product that performs well within its lane - smoothing fine lines, creating a nice base for makeup, and leaving skin softer. It's not going to replace professional treatments for deep wrinkles, and the skin reaction reports stop us from rating it higher. But at under eight pounds, with a formula that includes peptides and Q10, and with genuinely enthusiastic repeat buyers like wilko and Miss daisy coming back for tube after tube, it's doing something right for a lot of people.

If you do try it, remember Lou's accidental discovery: don't be stingy with the application. The difference between "this does nothing" and "my partner thinks I've had Botox" might just be half a squeeze more.

NIVEA Q10 Anti-Wrinkle Power Expert Wrinkle Filler Serum

Targeted wrinkle filler with Q10 and Bioxifill peptides. Smooths fine lines in minutes, works as a makeup primer, under eight pounds on Amazon.